A majority of European Internet users expect companies to ask for permission to track their activities online using cookies, privacy management company Truste said Thursday. But despite the 2009 introduction of the European Union's so-called cookie directive requiring just that, only a small minority of websites ask for visitors' consent, according to a survey by the company.
Websites can store cookies containing snippets of information on a visitor's computer, for example to remember the visitor's log-in details or other preferences. But the cookies can also be used to track visitors from site to site, allowing marketing companies to build up a picture of their interests or behavior and serve them targeted advertising.
In 2009, the E.U. updated the 2002 Universal Service directive on telecommunications directives, ordering E.U. member states to pass laws requiring websites to obtain explicit consent from Internet users before cookies can be stored. How that consent should be given is not specified in detail, leading to confusion among law makers and website owners about how to implement or comply with the cookie directive.
Web companies still seem reluctant to comply with the new rules. None of the 50 most popular sites in France and Germany show a pop-up asking for a user's permission to install cookies, while one-third of the top 50 sites in the Netherlands and 12 percent of those in the U.K. had taken "some steps to comply with the Directive with an on screen pop-up, banner or tab informing users about cookies on the site", Truste said.
Truste's view of what it takes to comply can best be illustrated by the behavior of its own websites. Truste.eu and Truste.co.uk display warnings inviting visitors to change their browsers' current cookie settings before continuing -- even when the visitors are outside the E.U. However, there's no such protection for visitors to Truste.com, which only displays the warning to visitors in the U.K. where, the organization warns website operators, the E.U. cookie directive is now being enforced. No such warning is displayed on Truste.com to visitors from outside the E.U., or from E.U. member states including Belgium, France, the Netherlands or Romania. The company will use geolocation technology to display the warning to visitors from other countries as the directive goes into force, a representative said Thursday.
A pop-up warning is not the only way to inform visitors: Some of the sites in Truste's survey that did not show pop-ups did discuss the use of cookies in a privacy policy. The average length of the policies across all the sites checked by Truste was over 2,323 words, taking on average 10 minutes to read, the company said.
Truste analyzed consumer attitudes to data privacy and company practices across the E.U. in its E.U. Consumer Privacy Index. The study included more than 4,000 consumers in France, Germany, the Netherlands and the U.K., and audited the cookie practices of the top 50 websites in each country as ranked by Alexa.com.
The consumers were highly aware of cookies and their function, and expect online companies to ask for permission to use them, Truste said. Close to 90 percent of the Dutch respondents were aware of cookies, while 81 percent of the British respondents, 78 percent of the Germans and 59 percent of the French said they knew about cookies, the research showed.
Awareness of the cookie directive was lower, with 79 percent of the Dutch, 63 percent of the Britons, 51 percent of the Germans and 26 percent of the French respondents aware that the directive required websites to ask for explicit consent from users to install cookies.
The research showed a significant gap between consumer expectations and the experience provided by most companies, Truste said, adding that the majority of E.U. consumers are aware of the trade-off between the provision of free online services, content and games, and online targeting by advertisers.
Sites warning about their cookie use, in addition to complying with the law, are likely to encourage, rather than discourage, visitors, according to Truste's survey. It found that 41 percent of European Internet users plan only to visit sites that comply with the directive by announcing their use of tracking cookies, while in even the most suspicious of countries, France, fewer than 36 percent will not visit websites because of concerns about their privacy that cookie use might provoke.